|
|
Issue 1, March 2001
Remembering the Humanity of Medicine
George Lui
Yale University School of Medicine
George was one of the original five founding members of
JYI and served as the Publications Coordinator during his term on the Board of Directors.
Currently, he is on the JYI Board of Advisors.
RS is a 34-year-old,
African female with diffuse abdominal pain, which she has suffered
for the past week. The pain is located in the mid-epigastrum and
radiates laterally. There is no pain in her back. She describes
the pain as dull and constant. The pain is relieved with food. She
denies nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, or constipation. She has no other
past medical history.
But who is RS?
* * * * * *
Ruth lives in Washington
Heights in New York, New York - a neighborhood largely populated
by legal and illegal immigrants. She recently fled to the United
States from Sierra Leone with her two children. Her husband was
caught by military officials during their escape. She has been in
the United States for about three to four months. She is currently
living in a small room with a friend. Because of the constant needs
of her children, she rarely has time for herself. She feels depressed
and anxious about the future, unsure whether she has the strength
to survive in this city and country.
* * * * * *
Both versions of
her story are important. How are they related? Does she have a pathophysiological
disorder like gastritis or an ulcer? Are her physical complaints
related to her depressed mood?
For centuries,
we, physicians, have been trained to elicit the patient's story.
Then, we translate the patient's complaints into symptoms, which
lead to a diagnosis. We standardize the individual's story so that
we may communicate amongst each other. Our questions are targeted
and focused upon the matter at hand. In these times of managed care
and time constraint, our interactions with the patient have become
further constrained and limited. How do we balance compassion with
time?
During my third
year of medical school, I watched physicians stride in and out of
the examination room of an outpatient clinic within ten minutes.
As I sat in the room across from this lady, I thought about the
number of patients that were awaiting their appointment in the hallway.
I continued to elicit these vague complaints, unable to pinpoint
their origin. I was frustrated and prepared to end our discussion
with a prescription of Mylanta for indigestion. Then, I decided
to ask something unrelated to her physical complaints: "Why
did you come to the United States?" It was an open-ended question
that gave her the freedom to lead our discussion. She looked up
at me with weary lines around her eyes, frightened to reveal her
story. For a moment, she hesitated to begin. Then, a flood of images
rapidly came into our interview: the cramped, dark room in Washington
Heights, the other stowaways in the ship across the Atlantic, and
the soldiers surrounding the house. Tears welled in her eyes and
began to fall; I actively listened… the most important skill that
I have used in medical school.
Compassion is not
something that can be constrained by time. It need not be sacrificed
because we have only ten minutes with a patient. Our compassion
stems from the varied backgrounds, talents, and interests we developed
before entering medical school. The undergraduate years are a time
to explore and engage in these interests, whether they involve scientific
research, music, or sports. These are the embodiments of compassion,
because these activities make us human. They allow us to share the
human experience.
When a patient
begins to grasp her chest, finding it difficult to breathe, and
is unable to speak, you roll her stretcher to a monitoring station.
As you place her on 100% oxygen, your mind is focused upon the tasks
at hand. Step by step, you follow the methodology learned in medical
school: giving her an Aspirin to chew, placing EKG leads on her
chest, and calling for a cardiology consult. In the back of your
mind, you know that there is a chest X-ray in radiology you need
to glance at, that there is Tylenol you need to give a patient upstairs,
and that lunch/dinner has passed.
During this time,
I hope that you remember to take the extra five minutes to remember
that this patient has a story outside of her present symptoms. She
is not just a cardiac patient with hypertension and diabetes, but
a mother of two or an elderly woman who was a figure skater in her
youth.
Journal
of Young Investigators. 2001. Volume Three.
Copyright © 2001 by George Lui and JYI. All rights reserved.
|
|