|
|
Issue 3, September 2004
Psychological & Social Sciences
Aetiology of Schizophrenia: The "Neural Supernova" Hypothesis
Aaron Clarke
James Cook University
Advisor:
David Miller, Ph.D.
James Cook University
Abstract
Through this review article, “Neural Supernova”, a new
hypothesis to explain the aetiology of Schizophrenia is proposed.
According to this hypothesis, high levels of dopamine may result
from excessive biosynthesis of the amino acid tyrosine, the precursor
to dopamine. Possible mutagenesis of tryptophan synthetase or calmodulin,
and low Mg2+ and high Fe2+, may also result in “Neural Supernova”,
which is the rapid metabolic breakdown of glucose in the brain causing
psychosis and ischemia.
Introduction
Schizophrenia is a severe form of psychopathology in which personality
seems to disintegrate: perception is distorted, emotions are blunted,
thoughts are bizarre, and language is strange (Zimbardo 1985). One
percent of the general population will develop schizophrenia sometime
in life, and the cost to society is counted in billions of dollars
(more than twenty billion dollars per year in the United States
alone; Young et al. 1998). As a result, research into the causes
and the biochemical and physiological natures of schizophrenia is
vital. One such investigation focuses on the role of low Mg2+ and
high Fe2+ in creating negative allosteric effects that impair metabolic
function and regulation.
Review of the Literature
Effects of
Pharmacological Agents in Schizophrenia
A
study conducted by Hyman et al. (1995) has shown that psychostimulants
and dopamine stimulate the rat striatum, further activating gene
expression and the reward system in the rat brain. Thus, psychostimulants
such as amphetamine and cocaine were found to be involved in the
expression of c-fos mRNA and other immediate early genes (IEGs),
but blocked by dopamine receptor antagonists (i.e., antipsychotic
drugs). For example, the activation of the IEG gene prodynorphin
(involved in the encoding of endogenous opioid dynorphin peptides)
was found to stimulate D1 receptors in the striatum (Hyman et al.
1995) as a result of psychostimulants. Therefore, it is possible
that these genes are connected to schizophrenia. Antipsychotic drugs
counteract the stimulatory effects of IEGs by actively binding to
dopamine receptors, resulting in decreased dopamine activity and
an eventual recovery in psychosis sufferers. Consequently, it is
possible that inhibition of these genes could reduce the likelihood
of developing this disorder.
Dopamine
build-up may be caused by a faulty gene that codes for the enzyme
Dopamine-b-hydroxylase, which converts dopamine to norepinephrine.
Angst (1956) showed that blocking this enzyme with the drug disulfiram
results in psychosis indistinguishable from schizophrenia in alcoholics
who overdosed on disulfiram. According to Stein and Wise (1971),
some of the dopamine was autoxidized to 6-hydroxydopamine and caused
degeneration of peripheral sympathetic nerve terminals that resulted
in a marked and long-lasting depletion of norepinephrine. Evidence
supporting 6-hydroxydopamine as a neural degenerative agent of noradrenergic
nerve endings comes from the isolation and identification of an
odorous substance (known as trans-3-methyl-2-hexenoic acid, a metabolic
product of 6-hydroxydopamine) found in the sweat of schizophrenics.
Phenethylamine derivatives with the same 2,4,5- substitution pattern
as 6-hydroxydopamine were found to have high hallucinogenic activity
in humans.
New
atypical neuroleptic drugs such as Clozapine (dibenzodiazepine derivative)
have a relatively weak binding to D1 and D2 dopamine receptors,
as compared to traditional neuroleptic drugs. The drug also has
a potent binding affinity for serotonin receptors 5-HT1A and 5-HT2
(Jann 1991), so serotonin may be involved in schizophrenia. This
is because serotonin and dopamine have the same ethylamine side
chain, and this side chain makes their respective receptors active.
Therefore, dopamine receptors may not be able to distinguish between
serotonin and dopamine; as a result, serotonin may in fact stimulate
dopamine receptors. Bourson et al. (1995) found that the newly cloned
5-HT6 receptors were mediated through changes in cholinergic neurotransmission.
This study used antisense oligonucleotides to study whether or not
the receptor was expressed in rat brains and to study the resulting
physiological affects. Treatment with antisense oligonucleotides
and scrambled oligonucleotides produced a toxic response in some
rats that was found to be dose dependent. The toxic response was
due to the inhibition of RNA translation into the receptor protein
and not the oligonuleotide. The toxic response of the antisense
oligonulceotides may have resulted in increased cholinergic neurotransmission,
indicating that 5-HT6 receptors may control the levels of cholinergic
neurotransmission.
Biosynthesis
of Tyrosine
Chorismate
is the precursor of aromatic amino acids like tyrosine, phenylalanine,
and tryptophan; its production is through the shikimic acid pathway.
The first reaction in the shikimic acid pathway is between erythrose
4- phosphate and phosphoenolpyruvate; thus, high levels of these
compounds will favour chorismate production. A diet low in Mg2+
may retard pyruvate kinase, preventing the dephosphorylation of
phosphoenolpyruvate in the final step of glycolysis and favouring
chorismate production (Matthews and Von Holde 1996).
More
tyrosine may be produced in vivo by the conversion of phenylalanine
to tryrosine, a reaction catalyzed by phenylalanine hydroxylase.
An overactive phenylalanine hydroxylase could be responsible for
excessive biosynthesis of tyrosine, whereas a deficiency of this
enzyme is responsible for phenylketonuria (PKU). If phenylalanine
hydroxylase is overactive, then you might expect to find an imbalance
between the cofactor H4-biopterin and H2-biopterin, favouring the
latter. The rate at which dihydropteridine reductase converts H2-biopterin
to H4-biopterin may be slightly less than the phenylalanine hydroxylase
conversion of H4-biopterin to H2-biopterin. A diet high in iron
may further stimulate phenylalanine hydroxylase by acting as a co-factor,
favouring tyrosine production (Letendre 1975).
The
Role of Phenylacetic Acid in the Biosynthesis of Tyrosine and 6-Hydroxydopamine
Studies
have revealed that phenylacetic acid is one of the by-products of
dopamine catabolism. A high concentration of phenylacetic acid in
the cerebrospinal fluid and other bodily fluids of schizophrenics
is to be expected, because of its role as:
1.
A possible bio-indicator of tyrosine biosynthesis and/or intake.
2.
An alternative source of 6-hydroxydopamine (2,4,5-trihydroxyphenethylamine).
However,
phenylacetic acid (free) was found to be 21.2 ng/ml for controls,
12.8 ng/ml for schizophrenics on neuroleptic drugs, and 10.8 ng/ml
for schizophrenics off neuroleptic drugs (Hafner et al. 1987). If
cerebrospinal fluid is taken leading up to and during a psychotic
episode, the concentration of phenylacetic acid may be higher than
normal. According to Olivera et al. (1994), catabolism of phenylacetic
acid and 4-hydroxphenylacetic acid in Pseudomonas putida U occurs
in two unrelated pathways. Phenylacetic acid is involved in the
biosynthesis of phenylacetyl CoA, which goes into the citric acid
cycle. If this reaction occurs in humans and requires the same co-factor,
Mg2+, phenylacetyl CoA will not be biosynthesised according to this
reaction in the schizophrenic. Catabolism of phenylacetic acid via
one pathway will give succinic acid, while taking the other pathway
will give acetoacetic acid and fumaric acid. The work of Takeda
and Sugiyama (1993), on the metabolism of biogenic monoamines in
Tetrahymena pyriformis, indicates the formation of hydroxyphenylacetic
acid-4 from tyrosine-4. If a similar pathway occurs in humans, then
hydroxphenylacetic acid may indicate tyrosine biosynthesis and/or
intake. The formation of phenylacetic acid may in turn be formed
by the selective dehydroxylation of hydroxyphenylacetic acid. An
alternative source of 2,4,5-trihydroxyphenethylamine (6-hydroxydopamine)
may be found from a yet-to-be discovered pathway involving 2,4,5-
trihydroxyphenylacetaldehyde. Thus, phenylacetic acid may be involved
in the eventual biosynthesis of 6-hydroxydopamine. The reasoning
behind this possibility is the following:
1.
If phenylacetic acid is catabolized in humans, as is the case in
Pseudomonas putida U, then it will lead to the formation of 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic
acid, instead of leading to the eventual biosynthesis of succinic
acid. Evidence indicates that, in humans, the breakdown of dopamine
by the enzyme (Monoamine oxidase) results in the formation of homovanillic
acid (the end product of dopamine catabolism). However, the intermediate
product of this reaction is 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid (Summers
et al. 1979). It seems likely that monoamine oxidase plays a vital
role in phenylacetic acid formation. Such a process possibly found
in humans may occur differently. Therefore, in humans, this process
may involve 4,5 -dihydroxyphenylacetic acid being hydroxylated to
2,4,5-trihydroxyphenylacetic acid, which is converted to an aldehyde
to form 2,4,5-trihydroxyphenylacetaldehyde; finally, the aldehyde
2,4,5-trihydroxyphenylacetaldehyde is converted to 6 -hydroxydopamine
by reductive amination.
2.
Phenylacetaldehyde can form directly from phenylacetic acid in bacterium;
however, if this also occurs in humans, then the possible hydroxylation
at the 2,4,5 positions on the phenyl group, and subsequent reductive
amination, may also lead to 6-hydroxydopamine. Evidence in humans
indicates that the reaction of dopamine with the enzyme Monoamine
oxidase also results in the formation of (3,4-dihydroxyphenyl) acetaldehyde,
NH3, and H2O2 (Summers et al.
1979).
If this process is found in humans, it will highlight the relationship
between phenylacetic acid and 6-hydroxydopamine biosynthesis (see
Figure 1).
|
| Figure
1. Biosynthesis of 6-hydroxydopamine from phenylacetic
acid. |
The
Role of Iron in 6-Hydroxydopamine Biosynthesis
Fe2+
is oxidized to Fe3+ in the presence of an electron acceptor (e.g.,
O2) and then binds to apoferritin. Carboxylate resides (glutamate
or aspartate) are abundant at the inner surface of the apoferritin;
their conversion to ester groups causes the deposition and oxidation
of more Fe II, forming ferritin (Mann et al. 1989). However, the
autoxidation of Dopamine to 6-hydroxydopamine may result in its
ability to act as a reducing agent that can cause the release of
iron from cellular stores (accounting for oxidative damage to cell
membranes or nucleic acids). Hemochromatosis seems likely to occur
under these conditions and may contribute to increased skin pigmentation.
The
Role of Iron in DNA Translation
The
biosynthesis of nucleic acid may be adversely affected in schizophrenics.
Their ability to transcribe mRNA also seems to be affected. Pyrimidine-deoxynucleoside
1’-dioxygenase catalyzes the reaction between 2-deoxyuridine
and 2-oxoglutarate and requires iron and ascorbate to act as co-factors
in the biosynthesis of uracil (found only in RNA species; Stubbe
1985). While one would expect high levels of iron to stimulate this
reaction, this is not the case; the biosynthesis of 2-oxoglutarate
is altered due to the reduction of acetyl-CoA and Mg2+. Furthermore,
the biosynthesis of uridine is also changed because it has the same
substrates as uracil, except that it is catalyzed by a different
enzyme (Pyrimidine-deoxynucleoside 2’-dioxygenase; Bankel
et al. 1972).
Mutagenesis
of Trytophan Synthetase
Mutagenesis
may occur in the gene coding for tryptophan synthetase and may be
a genetic indicator of schizophrenia. According to DeMoss and Bonner
(1959), genetically altered tryptophan synthetase prevents the enzyme
from catalysing the formation of tryptophan and only catalyzes the
breakdown of indole-3-glycerol phosphate to indole and triose phosphate.
Catabolism of tryptophan results in the biosynthesis of NAD+, meaning
that inhibition of tryptophan will cause pellagra. However, dietary
intake of tryptophan may prevent this from happening, but a slight
reduction of NAD+ may affect the performance of dopamine-b-hydroxylase.
Fumarate is also involved in the stimulation of dopamine-b-hydroxylase,
and fumarate is produced by the reaction of succinate plus the coenzyme
FAD+ (Levin et al. 1960); however, the precursor to fumarate (2-oxoglutarate
and succinyl CoA) requires the coenzyme NAD+ (Matthews and Von Holde
1996). So, low levels of NAD+ may lower the concentration of fumarate,
thus acting as a negative allosteric effector. Dietary intake of
tryptophan and high iron levels may favor excessive biosynthesis
of serotonin. As H4-biopterin may act as a cofactor for serotonin
synthesis, iron may also act as a cofactor for the enzyme involved
in serotonin synthesis, as is the case for phenylalanine hydroxylase.
The
Role of Magnesium
If
there is no mutagenesis in tryptophan synthetase, the inability
to produce NAD+ and Acetyl CoA from the Kynurenine pathway of tryptophan
catabolism may be due to allosteric inhibition of the enzymes that
involved in its breakdown. Namely, low Mg2+ seems likely to inhibit
enzyme catalysis. For instance, tryptophan 2,3-dioxygenase is involved
in the conversion of tryptophan to N-formyl-kynurenine and its cofactor
is heme. However, heme biosynthesis may be affected in that its
starting materials (succinyl CoA and glycine) may be at low concentrations
due to low Mg 2+. Further investigation reveals that succinyl CoA
requires Mg 2+, and if this were the case, one would expect the
build up of the precursors of succinyl CoA. The biosynthesis of
succinyl CoA occurs in the mitochondrial matrix and the cytosol
of the cell. Its basic building block is either valine and/or isoleucine,
probably depending on availability of either amino acid. If isoleucine
is involved in the biosynthesis of succinyl CoA, then 2-oxoglutarate
or pyuruvate will be needed in the first reaction that is catalyzed
by the enzyme branched-chain amino acid aminotransferase (2.6.1.42).
The products of this reaction are (S)-3-methyl-2-oxopentanoate,
(S)-2-oxo-3-methylpentanoate, and ‘alpha’-keto-’beta’-
methylvalerate. These products are then catalyzed by 3-methyl-2-oxobutanoate
dehydrogenase (1.2.4.4) and the next reaction then requires Mg 2+,
as the cofactor for (2.3.1.-), so a build up of the product catalyzed
by (1.2.4.4), namely, S-(2-methylbutanoyl) dihydrolipoamide and
S-(2-methylbutyryl) dihydrolipamide results. If valine is involved
in the biosynthesis of succinyl CoA, then 2-oxoglutarate or pyruvate
will be needed in the first reaction; as a result, low concentrations
of these compounds will prevent valine and isoleucine from being
incorporated into the biosynthesis of succinyl CoA. Once valine
has been converted to 2-oxo-3-methylbutanoate, 2-oxoisovalerate,
3-methyl-2-oxobutanoate (requires 2-oxoglutarate in first reaction
to obtain this compound) and ‘alpha’- ketoisovalerate,
it is then ready to be catalyzed by (1.2.4.4), which requires Mg2+
as its cofactor. Therefore, a build up of these compounds will indicate
three important factors:
1.
Which amino acid is involved in succinyl CoA biosynthesis (this
is determined by looking at the precursors).
2.
Where succinyl CoA biosynthesis is occurring in the cell, either
in the mitochondrial matrix and/or cytosol, as this is the case
for the valine. If 3-methyl-2-oxobutanoate is present, then succinyl
CoA must occur in the mitochondrial matrix, whereas 2-oxoisovalerate
must occur in the cytosol of the cell.
3.
Whether pyruvate and/or 2-oxoglutarate are required, as is the case
for valine but not isoleucine (which have same products). If pyruvate
is used, then 2-oxoisovalerate will be formed. If 2-oxoglutarate
is used, then 3-methyl-2-oxobutanoate will be formed.
So,
the inability to biosynthesize succinyl CoA will have an impact
at not only this point, but on other important biochemical processes
in the body as well.
The “Neural Supernova” Hypothesis
The Role
of Epinephrine in “Neural Supernova”
There
may be a reduction in the levels of Epinephrine in schizophrenics;
however, this might not be the case at all, but the complete opposite
(norepinephrine in controls was an average of 58.7 ng/g and in Schizophrenics
was 60.25 ng/g from the amygdala of post-mortem brains; Reynolds
1983; Reynolds 1986). Therefore, one would not expect low concentrations
of epinephrine to stimulate cAMP production that is activated by
cAMP dependent protein kinase (further stimulating glycogen breakdown.)
However, epinephrine in controls was 85 pg/ml. Patients on neuroleptic
drugs were found to be 330 pg/ml and patients off neuroleptic drugs
were 230 pg/ml [10]. In the schizophrenics’ case, activation
may be achieved by Ca2+ stimulation of calmodulin (if epinephrine
levels were low). The influx of Ca2+ through voltage-gated Ca2+
channels stimulates cells to secrete their neurotransmitters by
activation of CaM-kinase II to phosphorylate. This makes tyrosine
hydroxylase active, leading to the eventual biosynthesis of Epinephrine.
However, the rate at which norepinephrine is produced affects the
catalytic rate of tyrosine hydroxylase, thereby acting as a negative
allosteric effector. But, in the schizophrenic case, the rate in
which norepinephrine is synthesized remains constant; if phenylethanolamine
N-methyl transferase is low, then the biosynthesis of norepinephrine
will be favored instead of Epinephrine. But, this enzyme may be
overactive and therefore account for high levels of Epinephrine
as previously mentioned. This results in the uncontrollable production
of Dopamine by keeping the norepinephrine levels constant.
As
cAMP increases in the body, it results in a negative feedback mechanism
that induces phosphorylation of B2-adrenergic receptors. This desensitizes
the effect of epinephrine and prevents the depletion of glycogen
stores (cAMP level in controls was 14.5 pmol/ml, in patients on
neuroleptic drugs it was 9.2 pmol/ml, and in patients off neuroleptic
drugs it was 7.5 pmol/ml [10]). Inability to synthesize cAMP from
epinephrine stimulation may prevent this negative feedback mechanism
from coming into play in schizophrenics. This may be likened to
a “Neural Supernova” in that it burns fuel rapidly (i.e.,
there is glycogen breakdown by stimulation from Epinephrine) and
goes out in a bang (i.e., psychosis and brain starvation causes
neural death). The schizophrenic brain must work extra hard in glycogen
metabolism to try and catch up to production of ATP in non-schizophrenics.
Under normal conditions, glycolysis produces 4 ATP molecules and
invests 2 ATP, giving a net output of 2 ATP molecules; more ATP
molecules are synthesized via the citric acid cycle, fatty acid
metabolism, and electron transport mechanism. Reduction in the concentration
of NAD+ may result in the non-formation of acetyl-CoA from the b-oxidation
pathway, preventing its incorporation into the citric acid cycle.
Low concentrations of Mg2+ may prevent the formation of pyruvate
(in glycolysis), which would lead to its subsequent conversion to
acetyl-CoA. Precursors of acetyl-CoA may support this assumption.
Mutagenesis
of Calmodulin
Possible mutagenesis of calmodulin may lead to Ca2+ sensitivity
in schizophrenics. According to the “Neural Supernova”
hypothesis, uncontrollable Ca2+ stimulation of glycogen breakdown
will most likely lead to hypoglycaemia, contributing to cellular
death. If Ca2+ concentration increases in the cytosol as expected,
then the ATP produced by rapid glycogen breakdown will be needed
to stimulate Ca2+-ATPase to pump it out of the cell, further depriving
cells of much needed energy.
The
Role of Insulin in “Neural Supernova”
As
the hormone insulin is involved in glucose catabolism, it seems
likely that it plays a role in schizophrenia. In patients with diabetes
mellitus, deficiency in insulin results in the inability to catabolize
glucose and is characterized by a build up of glucose in urine.
In schizophrenics, increased levels of insulin, and/or insulin hypersensitivity
due to the increase in the number of insulin receptors and/or IGF-I
receptors, may further stimulate “Neural Supernova”.
Therefore, the increase in the production of insulin receptors and/or
IGF-I receptors may be due to male sex hormones, possibly accounting
for a slight disposition toward males and the early onset of schizophrenia.
However, increased levels of insulin may be due to by-products of
“Neural Supernova”, namely, serotonin. Insulin inhibits
the breakdown of glycogen and the conversion of amino acids or fatty
acids to glucose. Stimulation of 5-HT6 receptors by serotonin as
previously stated may mediate cholinergic neurotransmission. Acetylcholine
targets the pancreas to release insulin, so serotonin produced during
“Neural Supernova” may inadvertently stimulate insulin
release. Increased insulin levels may prevent glucose from being
metabolised, thus depriving cells of much need energy. Under these
conditions, ketone bodies may provide the necessary energy needed
by the starving brain (with ketoacidosis side-effect.) As ketone
bodies are anions, they will probably affect cations, namely, sodium
and potassium, and may even account for possible depletion of magnesium
in the schizophrenic.
Physiological
Effects of “Neural Supernova”
The
“Neural Supernova” feedback mechanism will now be activated
in the brain, resulting in negative feedback. This leads to the
stimulation of dopamine b-hydroxylase that will convert excess dopamine
to norepinephrine and negate tyrosine hydroxylase. Glycogen breakdown
will now be arrested and glycogen synthetase will be stimulated
when glucose-6-phosphate levels have recovered. Evolutionary processes
built into the mammalian brain have enabled it to survive hypoglycemia
and reduce neural damage. This is achieved by the stimulation of
hormones by the products of “Neural Supernova” (e.g.
serotonin, tyrosine and possibly histamine). Therefore, histaminergic
and serotoninergic neurons may induce adrenocorticotropin (ACTH)
and b-endorphin release, resulting in the synthesis or activation
of metabolic regulatory enzymes and other compounds capable of turning
off the “Neural Supernova” stimulus. ACTH will cause
the synthesis of tyrosine aminotransferase to help control the excess
biosynthesis of tyrosine, and may contribute to the biosynthesis
of fumarate, thus stimulating dopamine b-hydroxylase. ACTH also
stimulates pro-opinomelanocortin, which stimulates various forms
of melanocyte-stimulating hormone (MSH). MSH may help convert excess
tyrosine and DOPA to polymeric black and red melains. The production
of polymeric black melanins is catalyzed by tyrosinase, which is
inhibited by tyrosine, so it seems that polymeric black melanins
will be inhibited, favoring polymeric red melanin production. However,
cysteine levels will affect polymeric red melanin production and,
if cysteine were not available, then one would expect a build up
of dopaquinone and DOPA. However, there will most likely be a greater
build up of DOPA, as high levels of Cu2+ will act as a co-factor
for tyrosinase, and “Neural Supernova” stimulus produces
excess DOPA. If there are abundant levels of cysteine, increased
melanin production may lead to the slight darkening of skin in schizophrenics.
Protein
metabolism may be the only possible source for pyruvate and acetyl
CoA to produce ATP – the end product is NH3. Another source
of NH3 is the irreversible aminohydrolysis of 5’-AMP to equimolar
amounts of 5’-IMP. Under ischaemic conditions, protein kinase
C is activated and phosphorylates AMP aminohydrolase. However, normal
concentrations of ATP inhibits it, but decreasing levels of ATP,
due to ”Neural Supernova,” reduces its role as an inhibitor
towards AMP aminohydrolase, adversely affecting the purine nucleotide
cycle. Cerebral ischemia may be a major factor in the cause of Schizophrenia,
primarily causing the release of high levels of Ca2+ ions and stimulating
“Neural Supernova.” One possible use of NH3 is in glutamine
synthesis, which is ATP-dependent and highly regulated. The products
of “Neural Supernova,” including serotonin, may stimulate
ACTH, which in turn may stimulate the synthesis or activation of
glutamine synthetase and tryptophan oxygenase. These enzymes are
involved in tryptophan biosynthesis and its conversion to NAD+,
favoring dopamine b-hydroxylase stimulation. Another product of
“Neural Supernova” is tyrosine, which is involved in
the stimulation of thyroid hormones that synthesize or activate
the enzyme carbamoyl phosphate synthetase (involved in NH3 assimilation).
Intracellular acidosis caused by cerebral ischemia results in the
production of carbonic acid, which deprotonates to form a carboanion
that is required in the production of carbamoyl phosphate and glutamate.
Ammonia or glutamine can serve as nitrogen donors. If the nitrogen
donor is ammonia, then it will react with the carboanion and ATP
to produce carbamoyl phosphate. Likewise, if the nitrogen donor
is glutamine, then it will react to form carbamoyl phosphate and
glutamate. The carbamoyl phosphate that is produced goes into the
Kerbs-Henseleit urea cycle and forms urea, the end product of protein
metabolism. Abnormal levels of urea in the urine of schizophrenics
may imply high protein metabolism.
Increased
Ca2+ /calmodulin caused by cerebral ischemia may result
in the stimulation of NO synthetase that will produce NO and L-cistrulline.
NO may counteract ischemia by relaxing blood vessels in the brain,
thereby allowing better O2 delivery to neurons. L-cistrulline
produced will go into the Kerbs-Henseleit urea cycle to form urea;
therefore, it may account for abnormal levels of urea in the urine
of schizophrenics.
Discussion
Overview
of Neural Supernova Biochemical Pathways
The
brain of a person with an inherent disposition towards schizophrenia,
when placed in a stressful situation, will activate the “Fight
or Flight” response. Activation of this survival response
in the schizophrenic will trigger “Neural Supernova,”
the rapid metabolic breakdown of glucose leading to psychosis and
neural death. Inefficient metabolism of glucose, during glycolysis,
may be due to low Mg2+, which will favor chorismate production and
lead to excess biosynthesis of tyrosine (the precursor of dopamine).
Dopamine and
psychostimulants activate the reward system and expression of c-fos
mRNA and other IEGs, but are blocked by dopamine receptor antagonists
(i.e., antipsychotic drugs). Antipsychotic drugs counteract the
stimulatory effects of dopamine, psychostimulants, and IEGs by actively
binding to the dopamine receptor, resulting in a decrease in dopamine
activity and recovery in people suffering from psychosis.
In humans, the
breakdown of dopamine by monoamine oxidase results in the formation
of homovanillic acid and the following intermediate products: 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic
acid, 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetaldehyde, NH3, and H2O2. As dopamine
is catabolized by monoamine oxidase in humans, it seems likely that
the intermediate products of its breakdown could be converted back
to dopamine or its analog 6-hydroxydopamine.
An increase
in iron concentrations (most likely due to 6-hydroxydopamine acting
as a reducing agent) will stimulate phenylalanine hydroxylase, converting
phenylalanine to tyrosine. As a result, increasing levels of tyrosine
will favor dopamine synthesis. Excess dopamine will be auto-oxidized
to 6-hydroxydopamine, which will inhibit norepinephrine formation
and favor epinephrine. Inhibition of norepinephrine will prevent
it from acting as a regulator of dopamine concentration. Without
this control mechanism, epinephrine will rapidly consume glycogen
and lead to hypoglycaemia. The inability of the schizophrenic brain
to produce enough ATP molecules will force it to rely on other metabolic
pathways, thereby increasing the concentration of Ketone bodies.
Consequently, an increase in ketone bodies will lower the concentration
of Magnesium, further compounding the effects of “Neural Supernova.”
Mutagenesis
of tryptophan synthetase could be a genetic indicator of schizophrenia
because of its role in the biosynthesis of tryptophan. Insufficient
levels of tryptophan will affect the concentration of fumarate,
which, in turn, will inhibit dopamine-b-hydroxylase. However, increased
levels of iron and dietary intake of tryptophan may favor serotonin
synthesis. Therefore, serotonin produced during “Neural Supernova”
may also stimulate the release of insulin from the pancreas. Insulin
secretion will inhibit glycogen breakdown, further lowering the
concentration of glucose in the brain.
Protein metabolism
may be another source of energy during “Neural Supernova”
as its end product is NH3. Possible uses of NH3 include being a
nitrogen donor to inhibit the products of cerebral ischemia and
being involved in glutamine synthesis. Furthermore, the products
of “Neural Supernova” (i.e., serotonin) may stimulate
ACTH to activate glutamine synthetase and tryptophan oxygenase.
These enzymes are involved in tryptophan biosynthesis and its conversion
to NAD+, further favoring dopamine-b-hydroxylase.
Possible mutagenesis
of calmodulin may lead to calcium sensitivity in schizophrenics
due to uncontrollable Ca2+ stimulation of glycogen breakdown, contributing
to hypoglycemia and cellular death. Increased Ca2+/calmodulin may
result in the stimulation of NO synthetase, which will counteract
ischemia and may account for abnormal levels of urea in the urine
of schizophrenics.
General
Features of Neural Supernova
The general
make-up of a schizophrenic may be the following:
1. Normal to
below normal weight, due to high metabolism (from epinephrine stimulation
of glycogen breakdown).
2. Slight disposition
toward males, resulting from possible male sex hormone involvement
in insulin receptor and/or IGF-I synthesis and hypersensitivity
to insulin (which is further compounded by increased production
of insulin by acetylcholine stimulation of pancreas to secrete insulin).
3. Slight increases
in pigmentation of skin due to DOPA conversion to melanin.
4. Abnormal
levels of urea, indicating high protein metabolism and/or NO counteracting
cerebral ischemia which come into play during “Neural Supernova”
and lead to hypoglycaemia.
A “Neural
Supernova” may occur in cycles, indicating that psychotic
episodes are cyclical; however, psychotic episodes get longer and
recovery takes more time due to neural burnout. Treatment with neuroleptic
drugs may result in weight increase due to the drugs’ ability
to slow down metabolism (but this may be dose dependent).
In
the end, schizophrenia may be due to dietary factors that affect
their respective enzymes: low Mg2+ (ketone bodies may
result in hypomagnesia) and high Fe (ferritin breakdown leads to
free Fe in the cells.) Also involved is the possible mutagenesis
of tryptophan synthetase, leading to subsequent deactivation of
dopamine-b-hydroxylase and its inability to cope with the excessive
amounts of dopamine being produced. Calmodulin mutagenesis leads
to Ca2+ sensitivity and/or cerebral ischemia and results
in the “Neural Supernova”, which eventually leads to
hypoglycaemia. Finally, arrest in mRNA transcription leads to an
inability to synthesize regulatory proteins and enzymes, further
compounding the illness. For a complete overview of the Neural Supernova
pathways, see Figure 2.
|
| Figure
2. Overview of Neural Supernova pathways. |
Future
Research & Impact
Future research
into the phenomena of “Neural Supernova” could lead
to better ways of treating schizophrenia – perhaps even resulting
in a cure. Therefore, if the observations presented here have enough
validity regarding the aetiology of schizophrenia, new medicines,
with fewer side effects, could be tested and used in this condition
by addressing the faulty metabolism of glucose in the schizophrenic
brain. A better understanding of the impaired function of glucose
metabolism could lead to drugs specifically targeting this area.
This could contribute to a more beneficial outcome with people diagnosed
with schizophrenia, including quicker recovery from psychosis with
less neural damage.
References
Angst J. (1956). Med. Wochenschr. 46:1304.
Bankel
L et al. (1972). The Journal of Biological Chemistry.
247(19):6128-6134.
Bourson
A et al. (1995). Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental
Therapeutics. 274 (1):173-180.
DeMoss
JA and DM Bonner. (1959). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 45:1405-1412.
Hafner
H et al. (1987). “Search for the causes of Schizophrenia.”
Springer-Verlag. Berlin:242.
Hyman
SE et al. (1995). Chemical Senses. 20(2):257-260.
Jann
MW. (1991). Pharmacotherapy. 11(3):179-195.
Letendre
CH et al. (1975). The Journal of Biological Chemistry.
250(17):6672-6678.
Levin
EY et al. (1960). The Journal of Biological Chemistry.
235(7):2080-2086.
Mann
S. et al. (1989). “Biomineralization: Chemical and
Biochemical Perspectives.” VCH Verlagsgesellschaft.
Weinheim, Federal Republic of Germany.
Matthews
CK and KE Von Holde. (1996). Biochemistry. 2nd ed. Benjamin/Cumming
Publishing Co. Menlo Park, California.
Olivera
ER et al. (1994). European Journal of Biochemistry.
221(1):375-381.
Reynolds
GP. (1983). Nature. 305:527-529.
Reynolds
GP. (1986). “Amydala dopamine asymmetry in Schizophrenia.”
Dopaminergic systems and their regulation. Macmillan, London:285.
Stein
L and CD Wise. (1971). Science. 171:1031-1036.
Summers
MC et al. (1979). Biochemistry. 18(10):1969-1979.
Takeda
N and K Sugiyama. (1993). Comparative Biochemistry & Physiology
Part C: Comparative Pharmacology & Toxicology. 106(1):63-70.
Young
AS et al. (1998). Archives of General Psychiatry.
55(7):611-7.
Zimbardo
PG. (1985). Psychology and Life. Scott Foreman and Company.
Glenview, Illinois.
Journal of Young
Investigators. 2004. Volume Eleven.
Copyright © 2004 by Aaron Clarke and JYI. All rights reserved.
|
|